Stashing a few certificates of deposit in your
portfolio is a good way of investing cash, as long as you hold them
to maturity.
Cash them out early and you'll
likely pay early-withdrawal penalties.
No maximum
When buying a CD at a bank, the banker will remind you of the early-withdrawal
penalty. But it can be a lot like hearing the side effects of a
prescription drug being touted in a TV ad.
All you really hear is, "Ask your doctor about
Sneezeless, it will make your allergy symptoms go away." The
fast-talking mumble jumble about "may cause hallucinations,
sore feet and pimples" gets lost in the euphoria of knowing
you won't sneeze anymore.
You may focus so much on the interest rate and term
of a CD that you don't pay enough attention to the chatter about
how much money you'll give up if you cash the CD early.
Federal law requires a minimum penalty of seven days
interest for early withdrawal on any account classified as a time
deposit. Since the law doesn't set a maximum penalty, banks are
free to, and usually do, charge much more.
It's not unusual to see the following penalties:
30-days:
All interest
Two to 18 months:
Three months
Two years or more:
Six months
Some institutions levy even stiffer penalties. Chase
Manhattan charges 180 days interest for early withdrawal on a 12-month
CD.
And it's not just mega-banks that charge high rates.
Community Savings, based in Riviera Beach, Fla., charges six months
interest for early withdrawal of any CD with a term of more than
one-year.
Banks count on your money
Banks have a vested interest in making sure you don't yank your
money out from under them.
"We view CDs as one of a number of very important
investment tools, not only for the safety and soundness of a financial
institution, but also for the better returns than a money market
and less risk than the stock market," says Dave Huiskens, first
vice president at Detroit-based Comerica.
"But offsetting the security and the slightly
better yield is the fact that the bank is looking to keep those
funds around and share in the profitability."
Some banks, such as Comerica, don't state the specific
penalty at the time of purchase. The penalty will be determined
using a formula driven, in part, by the maturity point of the CD,
according to Huiskens.
"The earlier the withdrawal is made in the term,
the larger the penalty," he says. "The current market
rate at the time of withdrawal would also be considered."
What's worse than forfeiting interest you've earned?
Forfeiting interest you haven't earned.
Suppose you bought an 18-month CD at Chase and decided
to cash it out after four months. You would have to pay six-months
interest even though you've only earned four. That means you're
digging into the principal you paid for the CD.
On the other hand, early withdrawal penalties are
sometimes waived.
Penalty-free early withdrawals
"There are some exceptions," says Theresa Brooks of Community
Savings. "It's waived if someone dies or is declared mentally
incompetent. Most institutions will also waive it on an IRA or 401(k)
for anyone over 59 ½.
"A lot of people put their money into a CD for
the highest available interest rate and then set it up for monthly
withdrawal."
Early-withdrawal penalties are deductible if you itemize
on your tax return.
There is another way to invest in CDs and possibly
not pay a penalty for early withdrawal.
Brokered CDs, CDs bought through a deposit broker,
are sometimes advertised as not having a penalty for early withdrawal.
That's true in that no penalty is levied, but what you're doing
is selling that CD on a secondary market and accepting what you
get for it. You could get less than you paid originally.
Jason Flurry, CFP of Flurry Financial in Roswell,
Ga., says that when selling a CD on the secondary market your concern
is the interest rate.
If you have a three-year CD at 5.5-percent interest
and you want to sell at a time when the highest rate on a three-year
CD is 4 percent, you'll get a premium for your CD. But if you're
strapped for cash and have to sell when the current best rate on
a three-year is 6 percent, there's less demand for your CD and you
may have to sell it at a discount.
"It's a way to escape the early withdrawal penalty,"
says Flurry. "But the penalty may be better than what you can
get on the secondary market. You're signing away penalty rights
when you get a brokered CD.
"With every investment there's a benefit and
a burden. Typically, you'll get a higher rate with a brokered CD.
That's the benefit. The burden is if you have to cash it in early
you have absolutely no idea what you'll be able to sell it for.
At a bank you know the rules up front."
Nevertheless, Flurry says brokered CDs can be the
best deal for people who buy and hold. If you know you're not going
to need the money for two years, he advises checking out two-year
brokered CDs - but don't plan on cashing in early.